Naltrexone vs Acamprosate: Which Is Right?
The choice depends less on which is stronger and more on whether you have already stopped drinking.
Naltrexone and acamprosate are both FDA-approved for alcohol use disorder, and they are not competing versions of the same thing. They act on different systems and suit different situations.
The core difference
Naltrexone
For reducing drinking or stopping
Blocks opioid receptors, reducing alcohol's reward. Can be started while you are still drinking. Taken once daily. Best evidence for reducing heavy drinking.
Acamprosate
For staying stopped
Thought to help stabilise glutamate and GABA signalling disrupted by chronic drinking. Generally started after abstinence has begun. Taken three times daily.
Which tends to suit whom
If you are still drinking and want to drink less, naltrexone is the more natural starting point — it targets the reward loop that makes cutting down hard, and it does not require you to stop first.
If you have already stopped and the challenge is staying stopped, acamprosate is designed for that phase, addressing the lingering unsettledness that can follow sustained drinking.
Practical factors matter too. Acamprosate's three-times-daily schedule is harder to sustain than a single daily dose. Kidney function affects acamprosate; liver function and any opioid use affect naltrexone.
Talk it through with a provider
A 45–60 minute video evaluation with a board-certified psychiatric provider. Same-week appointments are typical.